Cookie Policy
We use cookies to enhance your experience. By clicking "Accept All Cookies" or selecting "Necessary Cookies", you agree to our cookies policy.
Necessary Cookies Accept All Cookies
Imperial & Legal

Civil penalties for illegal working in the UK: employer defence 

Support for employers at every stage: risk review, Home Office responses, objections and appeals against penalties, sponsor licence protection and new checks

up to £60,000 penalty per worker
28 days to lodge an objection
30% prompt payment discount

If the Home Office finds that a business is employing someone who does not have the right to work in the UK, the employer can be issued with a civil penalty of up to £60,000 for each illegal worker. The penalty can be avoided if a right to work check was carried out correctly before the work started. If a penalty notice has already arrived, the employer has 28 days to object and can then appeal to the court.

Since 1 October 2026 the rules have been tighter: the duty to check the right to work now applies not only to employers of staff, but also to businesses that engage individuals under worker’s contracts, individual sub-contractors and online matching platforms. This page explains how the penalty is calculated, what counts as a legal defence, what to do after a Home Office visit and how to protect a sponsor licence.

What a civil penalty for illegal working is and who receives it

A civil penalty is a financial sanction that the Home Office imposes on an employer without going to court. The legal basis is section 15 of the Immigration, Asylum and Nationality Act 2006: it is unlawful to employ an adult who has no permission to enter or stay in the UK, whose permission has expired or become invalid, or whose permission includes a condition that prevents them from doing the work in question.

A key feature of the regime is that liability does not depend on intent. An employer may honestly not know that a worker has lost the right to work and still receive a penalty. The only protection is a statutory excuse — evidence that the correct check was carried out at the right time and properly recorded. If the employer knew about the worker’s unlawful status, the excuse does not apply at all, and the matter can become criminal.

Breaches come to light in different ways: an unannounced visit by Immigration Enforcement, a sponsor compliance visit, a report from a third party or data from other government departments. After a visit, the business may be told that its case has been referred to the civil penalty team and asked for information. This is the first point at which a well-prepared response directly affects the outcome.

Civil penalties for illegal working protect the UK labour market, and well-designed right to work checks allow businesses to hire overseas talent with confidence. For sponsor licence holders, they are also a condition of keeping the ability to recruit from abroad in the future. Imperial & Legal helps employers set up compliant checks, respond to Home Office requests and defend the business when a breach has already been identified.
Vasily Kluev
Client Service Director, Immigration Adviser (IAA)

A separate penalty is issued for each illegal worker. For a business with several such workers, the total quickly becomes significant even for a large organisation, and it can be critical for a small one.

Penalty amount: how the Home Office calculates the sum

The maximum penalty is up to £60,000 for each illegal worker, as stated on the GOV.UK page on penalties for employing illegal workers. The actual amount is calculated under the Code of practice on preventing illegal working, in the version in force from 1 October 2026.

The calculation starts from a fixed starting point. For a first breach it is £45,000 per worker. If the business has received a penalty or a warning notice in the previous three years, the breach is treated as a repeat breach and the starting point is £60,000. Mitigating factors are then applied.

Penalty calculation per worker under the Code of practice
FactorFirst breachRepeat breach
Starting point£45,000£60,000
Employer reported the suspicion to the Home Office and received a reference number−£5,000−£5,000
Active co-operation with the investigation−£5,000−£5,000
Amount with both mitigating factors£35,000£50,000
Plus effective right to work checking practicesWarning notice instead of a penaltyNot available
Payment within 21 days30% reduction (first penalty only, no instalments)Not available

The table shows that the employer’s conduct after a breach is identified has a direct financial value: reporting and co-operation reduce the amount by £10,000 per worker, and for a first breach with effective checking practices a warning notice may be issued instead of a penalty. A warning notice still counts, however: a new breach within three years will be treated as a repeat breach.

If the full amount cannot be paid at once, the Code allows payment by instalments over an agreed period, provided the employer explains why a single payment is not possible. An unpaid penalty is registered with the civil court, and enforcement action can begin immediately.

Key takeaways on the penalty amount

  • A separate penalty is calculated for each illegal worker
  • A first breach starts at £45,000, a repeat breach within three years at £60,000
  • Reporting to the Home Office and co-operation each reduce the amount by £5,000
  • A warning notice instead of a penalty is only possible for a first breach
  • The 30% reduction applies when a first penalty is paid in full within 21 days

Received a Home Office notice about a possible penalty?

Imperial & Legal supports UK employers on immigration compliance, from the first Home Office information request to an objection and court proceedings. Discuss your situation with an adviser before the response deadline passes.

New rules from 1 October 2026: workers, sub-contractors and platforms

Until autumn 2026 the duty to check the right to work applied only to employers hiring staff under contracts of employment. Businesses using individuals under worker’s contracts, sub-contractors or couriers through online platforms were largely outside the penalty regime. This was changed by section 48 of the Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Act 2025, and secondary legislation in force from 1 October 2026 put the changes into effect.

The penalty regime now covers:

  • businesses engaging individuals under a worker’s contract, where the individual personally performs the work or services
  • businesses engaging an individual sub-contractor to deliver work under their own contract with a third party
  • online services that match service providers with clients in return for a fee or commission
  • in some cases, businesses further up a chain of contracts, where the direct employer cannot be identified or checks were not carried out

There is a limit: for the new categories, a penalty can only be imposed where the engagement began on or after 1 October 2026. For contracts of employment, the regime continues to apply to employment that began on or after 29 February 2008. Individuals genuinely trading on their own account with their own clients are outside the new rules.

Since October 2026, the question of who actually works for a business has become a legal one, not just an HR matter. A business that engages workers, sub-contractors or couriers needs to know who carries the duty to check and how that check is recorded. Contracts and processes are best reviewed before the first inspection, not after it: fixing a procedure in advance is easier than proving it in a dispute.

In practice, the new rules matter most in construction, logistics, delivery, cleaning, hospitality and restaurants, where temporary workers and subcontracting chains are common. These businesses should reassess who carries out the check, what substitution clauses apply and whether written evidence of checks exists before work starts.

How a compliant right to work check protects against a penalty

A statutory excuse is the only reliable way to avoid a penalty in full. It arises when the employer carried out one of the prescribed checks before the work started, did it correctly and kept a record. The process is set out in the Home Office employer’s guide to right to work checks and on the GOV.UK page on checking a job applicant’s right to work.

Three ways to check the right to work
MethodWho it suitsWhat to do and keep
Manual check of original documentsBritish and Irish citizens, holders of documents from the prescribed listsCheck the originals in the person’s presence (in person or by video call), make copies and record the date of the check
Online check with a share codeForeign nationals with digital immigration status (eVisa)Check the status through the Home Office online service and keep the profile page
Digital check through a certified providerHolders of current British and Irish passports, or passports expired by no more than six monthsUse a provider on the government register noted as offering right to work checks and keep the output

Copies and check results must be kept for the whole period of the work and for two years after it ends. Importantly, physical Biometric Residence Permits (BRPs) are no longer accepted as proof of the right to work — foreign nationals prove their status online with a share code. If a worker cannot show documents, for example because they are waiting for a decision on an application made before their visa expired, the employer uses the Employer Checking Service and receives a Positive Verification Notice valid for six months.

Where the right to work is time-limited, a follow-up check is required on or before the date the permission ends. Follow-up checks are where businesses most often lose their protection: the initial check was flawless, but two years later the visa ran out and nobody checked the extension.

What a reliable right to work checking system includes

  • A single checking procedure for all employees and workers, without exceptions
  • Checks before the first working day, not after paperwork is completed
  • Selection of the checking method based on nationality and status
  • Retention of copies and results during the work and for two years after
  • A calendar of follow-up checks for staff with time-limited permission
  • Contract terms on checks for sub-contractors and intermediaries
  • Regular internal audits and training for HR staff
Warehouse manager and worker reviewing documents on a clipboard by shelves of boxes

Such a system not only protects against a penalty but also strengthens the employer’s position in a dispute with the Home Office: for a first breach, effective procedures combined with reporting and co-operation can lead to a warning notice instead of a financial penalty.

What else a business faces beyond the penalty

The financial penalty is the most visible consequence but not the only one. The Code of practice and the sponsor guidance list measures that for many businesses are more serious than the penalty itself:

  • revocation of the sponsor licence and a bar on reapplying for at least 12 months after the penalty is paid in full, and up to 5 years where more than one penalty is issued
  • publication of the business name in the list of non-compliant employers on GOV.UK
  • temporary closure of the business and a court compliance order
  • disqualification of a director
  • review of alcohol, late-night refreshment, taxi and private hire licences
  • seizure of earnings from illegal working

Criminal liability is a separate risk. An employer who knew or had reasonable cause to believe that a person did not have the right to work faces up to 5 years in prison and an unlimited fine. This is why the business’s position should rest on documents from the very start, not on verbal explanations.

For sponsor licence holders the consequences are particularly serious. The sponsor guidance (part 3) states that if a business is issued with a civil penalty for illegal working, its licence is likely to be revoked. This affects every employee working on a Skilled Worker visa: their permission is normally cancelled, and they need a new sponsor or must leave the UK. There is no right of appeal against licence revocation. More on what to do in this situation is on the page about a suspended or revoked sponsor licence, and on sponsor duties in general — on the UK sponsor licence page.

What to do after a Home Office visit: 5 stages

Deadlines in this procedure are strict, and every response from the employer affects the final amount. Below is how a business usually moves from the inspection visit to the end of the case, and what Imperial & Legal’s advisers do at each stage.

Timeframe: 1–3 days
Urgent review of the situation after a visit or notice

Urgent review of the situation after a visit or notice

Timeframe: 1–3 days
The consultation takes place at the office, by phone or by video call. Imperial & Legal’s advisers review the Home Office documents, identify which workers are in question and which checks were made for them. The client provides HR records and correspondence with the officers. The result is a clear assessment of the risks and a response plan that takes every deadline into account.
Timeframe: 1–2 weeks
Evidence gathering and response to the information request

Evidence gathering and response to the information request

Timeframe: 1–2 weeks
An information request from the Home Office gives the business a chance to show a statutory excuse. The advisers help locate and organise copies of checks, evidence of co-operation and any reports made to the Home Office. The client provides internal documents and explanations. The outcome is a reasoned written response that may reduce the amount or remove liability.
Timeframe: up to 28 days
Preparation and submission of an objection to the penalty notice

Preparation and submission of an objection to the penalty notice

Timeframe: up to 28 days
After a civil penalty notice, the employer may object in writing within 28 days of the date set out in it. The advisers analyse the calculation, check whether all mitigating factors were applied and prepare the objection with supporting evidence. The client agrees the position and signs the documents. The Home Office must respond within 28 days of receiving the objection.
Timeframe: 28 days to appeal
Court appeal or agreement on payment terms

Court appeal or agreement on payment terms

Timeframe: 28 days to appeal
If the objection is rejected, an appeal can be lodged with the County Court, or the Sheriff Court in Scotland, within 28 days. The advisers assess the prospects and the risk of paying the Home Office’s costs, and work with the lawyers conducting the court case. If an appeal is not worthwhile, they help agree an instalment plan. The result is a decision on the case or a clear payment schedule.
Timeframe: 2–6 weeks
Sponsor licence protection and audit of checks

Sponsor licence protection and audit of checks

Timeframe: 2–6 weeks
Alongside the penalty, a licence holder must respond to any suspension or revocation action. The advisers prepare responses to the Home Office and audit HR records, contracts with workers and the follow-up check schedule. The client receives a report with recommendations and updated procedures. The aim is to reduce the risk of a repeat breach and keep the ability to hire overseas staff.

Deadlines are decisive here: an objection lodged after 28 days is not considered, and missing the appeal deadline removes the right to challenge the penalty in court. This is why advice is best sought immediately after the inspection visit, not after the penalty notice arrives.

Common employer mistakes

Most penalties stem not from knowingly hiring illegal workers but from procedural errors. These are the mistakes that most often cost employers their statutory excuse:

  • the check was made after the first working day rather than before it
  • copies of documents were not kept or do not show the date of the check
  • a physical BRP was accepted instead of an online status check with a share code
  • no follow-up check was made when a worker’s visa expired
  • students worked more hours than their visa conditions allow
  • the check was “delegated” to an agency or sub-contractor without contractual safeguards or oversight
  • the business ignored a Home Office request or replied after the deadline

Another category of mistakes concerns the reaction to a breach that has already been found. Employers try to explain the situation verbally without documents, or pay the penalty straight away without checking the calculation. A properly prepared objection can reduce the amount, and for a licence holder every penalty paid affects the future of its sponsorship. If you are not sure your processes would withstand an inspection, a mock sponsor licence audit can test them in advance.

Employer defence

Support with a civil penalty for illegal working

Risk assessment

Review of Home Office papers and checks for each worker

Objection

Recalculation of the amount and an objection on time

Information request

Evidence of a statutory excuse and a written response

Licence protection

Home Office responses and an audit to keep sponsorship

Two colleagues discussing documents by an office window

Even when the scope of support is clear, the right strategy depends on the details: how many workers are involved, whether this is a first breach, whether the business holds a sponsor licence and what evidence of checks has been kept.

Benefits of seeking penalty defence support from Imperial & Legal

  • Assessment of the situation in the first days after a visit or notice
  • Calculation of the likely penalty, applying every mitigating factor
  • Communication in English or Russian and preparation of Home Office responses
  • Control of deadlines for responses, objections and appeals
  • Parallel work on the penalty and on sponsor licence protection
  • Audit of right to work procedures against the 2026 rules
  • Support by video call, by phone or at the London office

Work on a penalty often becomes a reason to review HR processes as a whole, from contracts with workers to compliance with labour law in England.

Documents to prepare for a Home Office response

The strength of an employer’s position depends on documents, so they are worth collecting before a penalty notice arrives. Usually you will need:

  • copies of documents checked at hiring with the date of the check, or saved online check pages
  • results of follow-up checks and Positive Verification Notices from the Employer Checking Service
  • contracts of employment, contracts with workers and sub-contractors, and substitution terms
  • timesheets, rotas and payroll records for the workers in question
  • internal instructions and right to work check logs
  • evidence that the business reported the suspicion to the Home Office, if it did
  • correspondence with the officers and records of the visit

Missing documents do not always mean the case is lost: even without a full statutory excuse, the amount can be reduced through mitigating factors. To achieve this, the business needs to show that it co-operated with the Home Office and corrected its procedures. A suspicion of illegal working can be reported through the official GOV.UK form.

Practical examples

The situations employers face are similar, but the solutions depend on the details. A few typical scenarios:

Restaurant: a worker’s visa expired without a follow-up check

At hiring, a chef showed a valid document and the check was carried out correctly. Two years later the visa expired and nobody made a follow-up check. In this situation there is no statutory excuse for the period after the visa ended, but the business can reduce the amount if it reports the problem itself, co-operates with the Home Office and shows that its procedures have been fixed.

Construction company: work through a chain of sub-contractors

Since October 2026, liability may fall on a business further up the chain if the direct employer cannot be identified. A main contractor needs to know which checks its sub-contractors carry out and should set this out in contracts before work begins.

Sponsor licence holder: breaches found during a compliance visit

During a visit, the officers found that there were no document copies for some employees. Alongside the risk of a penalty, the Home Office may suspend the licence. In this case the responses on the penalty and on the licence need to be prepared together so that the positions in the two procedures do not contradict each other.

Below are real stories of Imperial & Legal clients who faced Home Office inspections and sponsor licence issues.

Client stories on inspections and sponsor licences

Success stories
4 min

Reinstating Sponsorship Licence after Unexpected Home Office Visit

It has been nearly four years since Company A applied for and received a sponsorship licence for hiring foreign specialists in the UK....

Success stories
4 min

Reinstating Suspended Sponsor Licence after Unjustified Accusations

Travel Agency C’s main clients are Chinese tourists. Because of that, all employees need to have knowledge of Chinese traditions and culture and speak...

Success stories
3 min

Obtaining a UK Sponsorship Licence for a Care Home

It started with an unusual telephone call where we were offered cooperation. A caller could not explain properly how our companies could help each other, but in the end, we established what was...

One of these businesses described how unexpected the licence suspension after an inspection was, and why it was important to act quickly.

Our agency’s main clients are Chinese tourists. Therefore, we needed our employees to speak fluent Chinese and have a strong understanding of Chinese culture and traditions. We got registered as sponsors and employed several Chinese specialists. When the Home Office came with an inspection and suspended our sponsor licence, we were in shock. That could have jeopardised the entire business. But Imperial & Legal’s immigration advisors solved the problem.

Company C
British travel agency
Clients’ names and photos have been changed

The stories differ, but the lesson is the same: the earlier a business builds its position on documents, the more options it has.

Key points for employers

A civil penalty for illegal working in the UK is imposed without a court hearing, for each worker, and even when the employer did not know about the problem. Only a correctly performed and recorded right to work check protects the business, and since 1 October 2026 it is also required for workers, sub-contractors and platforms. If a breach has already been identified, the business has legal tools: mitigating factors, an objection within 28 days and an appeal to the court. For sponsor licence holders, a penalty almost always also means a risk of revocation, so action is needed on both fronts at once.

The information on this page is general and does not constitute individual legal advice. The outcome in a specific case depends on its circumstances and the Home Office rules in force at the time. Answers to common employer questions are below, and an overview of other services is in the section on UK immigration.

Civil penalties for illegal working in the UK — frequently asked questions

Can an employer receive a penalty without knowing the worker was working illegally?

Yes. A civil penalty is issued regardless of whether the employer knew about the worker’s unlawful status. The only protection is a statutory excuse — evidence that the prescribed right to work check was made before the work started and, where the right is time-limited, that a follow-up check was also made. If the employer knew about the breach, the excuse does not apply and the matter may be treated as a criminal offence. The employer’s main task is therefore not to prove they “did not know”, but to show records of checks made at the right time.

What is the maximum civil penalty per illegal worker in 2026?

Up to £60,000 per worker. Under the Code of practice, the starting point for a first breach is £45,000 and for a repeat breach within three years £60,000. Reporting a suspicion to the Home Office and active co-operation each reduce the amount by £5,000. For a first breach with effective checking practices, a warning notice may be issued instead of a penalty. The final amount depends on the circumstances of the case, and a first penalty can be reduced by a further 30% through prompt payment.

How long does an employer have to object to a civil penalty notice?

An objection must be made in writing within 28 days of the date specified in the civil penalty notice. The Home Office must consider it and respond within 28 days of receiving it. The objection can argue that the business has a statutory excuse, that the amount was calculated incorrectly or that mitigating factors were not applied. An objection lodged after the deadline will not be considered, so it is best prepared straight away, with copies of checks, HR records and evidence of co-operation attached.

Can a civil penalty be appealed to the court after the Home Office rejects an objection?

Yes. If the objection is rejected, the employer can appeal to the County Court in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, or to the Sheriff Court in Scotland. The deadline is 28 days from the date of the objection outcome. If the appeal fails, the business may be ordered to pay the Home Office’s reasonable costs, so the prospects of an appeal should be assessed in advance together with the risk of extra costs. An appeal does not pause the separate deadlines that apply to a sponsor licence, if the business holds one.

Is there a discount for prompt payment, and can the penalty be paid in instalments?

For a first penalty there is a 30% reduction if the full amount is paid within 21 days of the date of the notice. The reduction cannot be combined with instalments. Payment by instalments is possible by agreement with the Home Office: the employer must explain why a single payment is not possible. For sponsor licence holders, timely payment or an agreed instalment plan also matters for the licence decision. An unpaid penalty is enforced through the civil court, which may affect the business’s ability to obtain credit.

Since October 2026, do businesses need to check the right to work of self-employed individuals?

In some cases, yes. From 1 October 2026 the penalty regime covers worker’s contracts where the individual personally performs the work, individual sub-contractors and online platforms that match service providers with clients for a fee. A penalty in these categories is possible where the engagement began on or after 1 October 2026. Individuals genuinely running their own business with their own clients are outside these rules. Businesses that work through subcontracting chains should set out how checks are made in their contracts.

What happens to a sponsor licence if the business receives a civil penalty?

According to the sponsor guidance, if a civil penalty for illegal working is issued, the licence is likely to be revoked. A new application cannot be made until at least 12 months after the penalty is paid in full, and where more than one penalty is issued this period can be up to 5 years. Revocation affects every employee on a sponsored visa. Even a warning notice issued in the last 5 years can be grounds for revocation. There is no appeal against revocation, so the position on the penalty should take the sponsorship consequences into account.

How should an employer check the right to work of a British citizen?

British and Irish citizens cannot get a share code, so two methods are available. The first is a manual check of the original passport or another document from the prescribed lists in the person’s presence, with a copy and a record of the date. The second is a digital check through a provider on the government register that is approved to carry out right to work checks. It covers current passports and passports expired by no more than six months. Using an online share code check for British and Irish citizens is a common employer mistake.

How long must copies of documents and check results be kept?

For the whole period of the work and for two years after it ends. This applies to document copies from manual checks, profile pages from online checks and the output of digital checks through a provider. Records must be available on request from the Home Office. Sponsor licence holders also need to follow the separate record-keeping requirements in the sponsor guidance. If a record is lost, a statutory excuse cannot be recreated after the event, so it is sensible to keep an electronic archive with a backup.

Does the Home Office publish the names of businesses that receive civil penalties?

Yes. Details of employers issued with civil penalties for illegal working may be published on GOV.UK in regular reports. For a business this is a reputational risk that is hard to undo after publication. Information about a penalty may also be shared with other government bodies and taken into account in future applications by the business, including for a sponsor licence. Home Office reports on penalties issued are available in a dedicated section of GOV.UK.

Protect your business from an illegal working penalty

Imperial & Legal helps UK employers set up right to work checks, respond to the Home Office and protect their sponsor licence. Book a consultation to discuss your situation.

Imperial insights

Immigration
28 min

UK earned settlement 2026: how the new ILR rules will change the path to permanent residence

On 2 November 2026, Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood set out the final version of the earned settlement...

Immigration
24 min

How can I obtain a residence permit in Europe by purchasing property, and how much does it cost?

A residence permit in another country appeals to foreign nationals for a variety of reasons. The most...

Taxes
30 min

UK FIG regime vs Italy, Cyprus and Portugal: which new-resident tax regime fits you in 2026

The FIG (foreign income and gains) regime is the UK's relief for new arrivals: for the first four tax...

Whatsapp